The big screen and the small screen... together at last! Hurrah!
Topic locked

American Idol 05 (Split)

Wed May 11, 2005 1:45 pm

Okay, split time again.

Old Thread- http://www.pinkpt.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=15220

Wed May 11, 2005 2:00 pm

My predictions on the bottom 2:

Carrie
Bo

My prediction of who is leaving:

Carrie

My reaction that I lost my bet with my dad:

:cry:

Wed May 11, 2005 2:16 pm

It is my opinion that anthony should go home. He should have went home weeks ago. Everytime I see him he looks like he is struggling so hard to look cool and he is not. He needs to accept that and go with it, rather than trying to be some heartthrob he isn't.

Anyway, after anthony... I don't know. I think both Carrie and Vonzell are good, but Bo is still my favorite. So Anthony, the one of the girls, then the other, and Bo should win. That is how I would do it. Of course if it were up to me, the top group would have been different than what we are left with, so we'll just have to see how it goes.

Wed May 11, 2005 3:21 pm

Bo rocked.
Carrie sucked.
Anthony rocked.
Vonzell rocked.

I hope Carrie goes tonight.

Wed May 11, 2005 5:34 pm

carrie won't go. all the judges want her in the top two, and she'll be there.

i predict carrie will be in the bottom two, just for the shock factor, but she won't leave. anthony likely will. they don't want an all-white top three.


oh, you thought the results were based on the votes? think again.

Thu May 12, 2005 1:45 am

Welp... he's finally gone.
It's about time. :roll:

What's next weeks theme. Think they said.. judges' pick, then the contestants then the guest judge's pick... so 3 songs each.
Be interesting to see what songs are chosen.

Thu May 12, 2005 2:41 am

Aw. My friend will be dissapointed. :[

I have a feeling next week it will be Carrie.. sorry to all Anthony fans. He'll get a record contract. :)

Thu May 12, 2005 3:59 am

I AM SO SAD! JUST BECAUSE I COULDN'T GET THROUGH TO VOTE, HE LEFT!
Actually, I don't think 1 vote would have made much difference.
Anyways, I am sad to see him go.
Can someone find me Anthony Fedorov pictures?

Thu May 12, 2005 4:53 am

anthony's time was long-coming. he never should have beat out anwar or nikko or my beloved nadia. he seems like a sweetie, though, so i feel bad for him on that account, but talent-wise he shouldn't have even gone this far.

vonzell's been a bottom-three staple for a long time now. carrie's never been in the bottom. vonzell will be the next to go, and a bo/carrie finale, which is what everyone's been predicting for a while, is what we'll get. although i can see vonzell making it to the finale, but it'll be for a racially-balanced top two, and not for anything else. i'm honestly surprised she made it this far.

bo will most likely win because he's a white male, appeals to a wider range of people, and because carrie's a bit too kelly-like (AI's got that demographic covered, doesn't need another) and she's boring besides.

i will buy bo's album. i won't buy carrie's.

Thu May 12, 2005 3:04 pm

Carrie is pretty boring isn't she.
I mean the girl can sing.. don't get me wrong there, but when she's up on that stage... Meh.. is about all I can say for the performance.
It's like she got botoxed too many times so her facial features except for her mouth don't move.

Thu May 12, 2005 5:18 pm

No.
No.
No.
No.
No.

*hides in a closet*

Thu May 12, 2005 7:16 pm

skizzy the wonder lizard wrote:anthony's time was long-coming. he never should have beat out anwar or nikko or my beloved nadia. he seems like a sweetie, though, so i feel bad for him on that account, but talent-wise he shouldn't have even gone this far.

vonzell's been a bottom-three staple for a long time now. carrie's never been in the bottom. vonzell will be the next to go, and a bo/carrie finale, which is what everyone's been predicting for a while, is what we'll get. although i can see vonzell making it to the finale, but it'll be for a racially-balanced top two, and not for anything else. i'm honestly surprised she made it this far.

bo will most likely win because he's a white male, appeals to a wider range of people, and because carrie's a bit too kelly-like (AI's got that demographic covered, doesn't need another) and she's boring besides.

i will buy bo's album. i won't buy carrie's.


I honestly don't think race has anything to do with who's going to win as of now. If that was true, than wouldn't the past winners be Clay Aiken and Diana Degarmo instead of Ruben and Fantasia?

I'm just sayin'.

Thu May 12, 2005 8:01 pm

Think they were saying since a black woman and man.. and a white woman have won.... they think a white guy is going to win to sorta balance everything out.
That make sense?
Just guessing, but since that has been the topic of past posts I figured that was the reason :P heh

Thu May 12, 2005 8:03 pm

Saying that a contestant would win due to race would mean that American Idol is rigged. And I sincerely doubt that it is rigged, wouldn't make sense to me if it was.

Fri May 13, 2005 3:15 am

It wasn't really surprising that Anthony left. He should've left a while ago though. I dont think the judges like him very much either...
Topic locked