Pink Poogle Toy Forum

So, which one do you think is the best out of all of them so far? (I'm surprised to see that we don't have a poll on it... or do we? I've checked like 4 pages)

I liked the 5th one the most, possibly because Luna was a big part of it, and she rocks XD. Like my friend said, all of the books sort of have a different mood to them. Anyways, the 5th book was well planned out, with a lot of detail. I thought the 6th one was a little too rushed. The 3rd, 2nd and 1st books are a little too short, and the 4th one, while great, didn't really have the whole feeling of the 5th one.

Anyways, I thought that the worst one was the 3rd one, even though I know that a lot of people liked it. I thought that nothing much really happened in that book.

Oh, and please, don't say something like, "HP SUCKKSSS!!!" or anything, because even if you think it does, you should still think one of them is better than the others. So vote!

Book 4, for me, was the better so far. I was kind of tossing up between HP4 and HP6 but Goblet of Fire was alot more appealing, to me.

Prepare yourself, heathen! *launches turnips by catapult*

Yeah, that one's my favorite, most of the time.

My least favorite was the second, because it had no bearing on the actual saga, but I guess I can't say that anymore. So my least favorite is the fifth, because the writing style is like "jarring notes in a familiar song," and, well, did I mention that the third is my favorite?

The third book is my favorite, although I can't for the life of me really explain why exactly it is. I just felt like it was a good combination of plot twists, plot work, and some development of characters who come into play later in the series.

My least favorite was number two, I just didn't like it. It didn't seem to have much to do with the overall plot, I disliked Lockhart, etc. Although number five wasn't my favorite, I think it's "decent". Number four was great as well.

At first I hated number two so much that it made me stop reading HP for a few years. Now I must say it's my favorite.

I loved the 5th. All the dark-angsty-screamy-ness....-drool-

I can't stand CoS, though. It's unbearably boring for me....

Something about the 3rd book has always had me.

Order of the Phoenix is probably my favourite, followed by HBP and Azkaban.

We did, like a year ago. But it's outdated now, since HBP is out.

And you know, I used to loooove GoF, but I think HBP may've passed it. I voted HBP anyway.... GoF may still be my favourite. I dunno... I CAN'T CHOOSE! **cries**

HBP -> PoA -> GoF -> CoS -> SS/PS -> OotP.

In order

Exactly that!

Can't say I have a favorite. If I had to choose i'd say the 4th book. Was that the longest one?

The 1st one is the only one I read.
I tried to read the second one after, but ...I just got bored with the whole idea.

I second that order exactly. Provided that HBP is your favorite. lol.

That was the second longest one, if I recall correctly. I don't remember if HBP's longer or GoF.

I thought that no one would choose the first one as their favourite, but I guess I thought wrong, because I asked my friend this question and she said the first one because it was the most interesting.

My order:

OotP > GoF > HBP > CoS > PS > PoA

I can't stand Prisoner of Azkaban. Anyways, I really doubt that anyone's order here is the same as mine, it's too weird.