Hilary Duff or Avril Lavigne?

Paul · **Posted:** Sun Dec 12, 2004 9:33 pm

Neither.

i_love_starburst · **Posted:** Mon Dec 13, 2004 6:14 pm

38% voted for Avril? People, what are you doing? -_-

Kitten Medli wrote:

I dislike both of them, but I don't hate them at all and they do not suck. However, I do like Breakaway, which Avril wrote.. besides that.. no.

Av Lav wrote something?

Don't believe it.

Yoshi wrote:

Avril Lavigne writes (though she needs co-writers, at least she still writes a little)

Apparently she only changed a few words in the songs so her name would be in the credits. :/

Wahey, talk about Anti-Avril. :lol:

Sapphire Faerie · **Posted:** Mon Dec 13, 2004 9:08 pm

Niether. But if I had to choose one, I would choose Avril, she's kind of pretty.

**waves magic wand and poll moves to Entertainment Polls**

Bangel · **Posted:** Tue Dec 14, 2004 1:26 pm

I_Love_Starburst, do you have any evidence to the claim that Avril only changes a few words to her songs? If not, please do not spread rumors just for the sake of being anti-Avril. Starting stuff without evidence isn't anti-Avril. It's anti-Consideration to the people you are starting a rumor about. However, if you can support the claim, I'll shut up now.

Avril. Her words have meaning to me... Hilary Duff just sings a bunch of chicky crap.

Igg · **Posts:** 6288 **Joined:** Fri Jun 04, 2004 5:47 pm

I think if Avril does write the majority of her songs she should, frankly, be ashamed of herself.

i_love_starburst · **Posted:** Tue Dec 14, 2004 5:11 pm

Dawn2 wrote:

I_Love_Starburst, do you have any evidence to the claim that Avril only changes a few words to her songs? If not, please do not spread rumors just for the sake of being anti-Avril. Starting stuff without evidence isn't anti-Avril. It's anti-Consideration to the people you are starting a rumor about. However, if you can support the claim, I'll shut up now.

Avril. Her words have meaning to me... Hilary Duff just sings a bunch of chicky crap.

I've read it on some websites, and The Matrix (I think that's who she worked with) said that's all she did. I'm not "starting rumours" as you say, but never mind. I just can't stand the woman. :/ Sorry if I offended you Dawn, I know you like Avril. I'll try to keep my comments about Avril to myself. *runs away*

Kidwaiy · **Posted:** Tue Dec 14, 2004 11:24 pm

It seems like people hate both of them :roflol:

I like Avril.

Ammer · **Posted:** Wed Dec 15, 2004 12:20 am

i_love_starburst wrote:

Dawn2 wrote:

I_Love_Starburst, do you have any evidence to the claim that Avril only changes a few words to her songs? If not, please do not spread rumors just for the sake of being anti-Avril. Starting stuff without evidence isn't anti-Avril. It's anti-Consideration to the people you are starting a rumor about. However, if you can support the claim, I'll shut up now.

Avril. Her words have meaning to me... Hilary Duff just sings a bunch of chicky crap.

I've read it on some websites, and The Matrix (I think that's who she worked with) said that's all she did. I'm not "starting rumours" as you say, but never mind. I just can't stand the woman. :/ Sorry if I offended you Dawn, I know you like Avril. I'll try to keep my comments about Avril to myself. *runs away*

Expressing your opinions is allowed. Others shouldn't force their opinions on you. I learnt that the hard way.

I voted for Hilary. I don't mind Hilary's songs and I like Avril's new songs. But based on various interviews with Hilary and Avril, I'd like to say I like Hilary more.

And Ben Moody who worked with Avril on the song "Nobody's Home" said that Avril helped a lot with the song. And Ben doesn't like others taking credit for his work.

Bangel · **Posted:** Thu Dec 16, 2004 12:45 am

I didn't force my opinions on anyone. I just said it was unwise to be starting claims without real evidence.

I don't care about anti-Avril stuff. I don't like Avril's voice in the least. Her songs are just meaningful to me. I don't care if others don't like her. But I don't like people saying things that could possibly be untrue, which that could possibly be... unofficial websites are not a reliable source.

So don't treat me like the bad guy, kay? I don't care if you're anti-Avril or anti-Hilary or even anti-Yellowcard. But I do care if you say stuff about them you can't be sure is true.

Okay. Done with my morality speech.

Monique · **Posted:** Thu Dec 16, 2004 6:55 am

I used to like Avril, but that was a while ago! Since then i realised that she kinda can't sing at all, though to be entirely honest, and I hate admitting this, I'd probably pick her over Hilary Duff anyday!

Drake Redcrest · **Posts:** 912 **Joined:** Mon May 31, 2004 6:22 am

Neither. I don't think either has any talent.

Maureen · **Posted:** Sat Dec 18, 2004 3:56 am

Avril, I guess. I'm a loner: neither of them bother me.

Stephy · **Posted:** Sat Dec 18, 2004 4:16 pm

Hilary Duff's voice is like a person scratching a chalk board to my ears.

I can't stand her!

Tailseh · **Posted:** Sat Dec 18, 2004 8:51 pm

Hilary's acting is fine.. but I like Avril's singing better.. sooooo..
Avril.

Igg · **Posts:** 6288 **Joined:** Fri Jun 04, 2004 5:47 pm

Dawn2 wrote:

But I do care if you say stuff about them you can't be sure is true.
.

If none of us said things that we weren't 100% sure were true, there'd be a lot less to say.
There's room to be speculative

Pink Poogle Toy Forum

Hilary Duff or Avril Lavigne?

Who is online