The big screen and the small screen... together at last! Hurrah!
Topic locked

Tue Jul 26, 2005 4:43 am

Josephine wrote:As for the LoTR rip off comment, wern't the Chronicles of Narnia written before LoTR?

Funnily enough, C. S. Lewis (author of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe) was friends with Tolkien (author of the LOTR)! They were influenced by similar things, but I don't think they ripped off each other's work ;)

(Edit: Sorry, this was already mentioned. I missed reading some replies! :oops:)

I found this quite interesting (from here):
J.R.R. Tolkien in particular criticized Lewis's first Narnia book, The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. He thought that there were too many elements that clashed—a Father Christmas and an evil witch, talking animals and children.


And yeah, I'm really looking forward to this movie. I loved the books and old tv series when I was younger, and the fact that the same SFX people as those for the LOTR are working on it means that its going to look awesome, hopefully! :)

Tue Jul 26, 2005 10:36 pm

....Weird. My topic on this dies but this one stayed alive? Hm. nyway, yeah. Look fantabulous.

Wed Jul 27, 2005 3:11 am

Forest_Majesty wrote:If they destroy it (which movies love doing) I will just.....explode :x . I love the books, and I have a feeling about how this entire movie will be layed out...won't say much now :). But it looks alright, and I will most definitely see it!

ofcourse they will destroy it.
its a classic book with a massive fanbase, that is unfortunetly steeped in the groups known as "small children who wont mind" and "geeks"
look at lord of the rings.
The war of the worlds.
Dawn of the Dead. (oh how the remake sucks. you can see the cameramen for crying out loud! :x )
and innumberable remakes that i dont care to mention.

it is doomed to suck from the right-off, maybe ive just grown bitter over the years (well. yes i have) but remakes should be renamed to:
Film tiltle here: teh suxxorz!
just to show how bad it will be before i wast another fiver on a ticket to sit through two hours where my mind dribbles out my ears.

*wanders off rambling incoherantly about how the geeks shall one day inherit the world and the unbelievers cast before lord Setekh for pennance*
Topic locked