American Idol 05 (Split)

Fri Apr 01, 2005 4:58 am

Why is it that Simon is always right? he seems to know exactly what i'm thinking most of the time. And I loved what he said about Ryan Seacrest that time, he really isa boring host, and Simon said what I was thinking these last 2 years. And I'm not sorry for Jessica, she isnt likeable, so why should she continue. In the end its not about the best voices, but who seels more records.

Fri Apr 01, 2005 8:14 pm

My brother saw on ET (Entertainment Tonight) that Scott Savol was found to have had a criminal record. He was charged with abusing his girlfriend and this week's performance was the exact same song he had sung to her.

I'm going to look around the internet for an article about this but if it's true, he should be kicked out as they did in the past.

Fri Apr 01, 2005 9:22 pm

bluebubblegirl wrote:Why is it that Simon is always right? he seems to know exactly what i'm thinking most of the time. And I loved what he said about Ryan Seacrest that time, he really isa boring host, and Simon said what I was thinking these last 2 years. And I'm not sorry for Jessica, she isnt likeable, so why should she continue. In the end its not about the best voices, but who seels more records.

Ryan's cool. He makes the show funny, so leave him alone.

Fri Apr 01, 2005 10:05 pm

Naniwai wrote:
bluebubblegirl wrote:Why is it that Simon is always right? he seems to know exactly what i'm thinking most of the time. And I loved what he said about Ryan Seacrest that time, he really isa boring host, and Simon said what I was thinking these last 2 years. And I'm not sorry for Jessica, she isnt likeable, so why should she continue. In the end its not about the best voices, but who seels more records.

Ryan's cool. He makes the show funny, so leave him alone.

Have you seen the British hosts of the show, they make the show worth watching, even if you don't like it. I can't say that Ryan is terrible, but he just lacks that spark.

Sat Apr 02, 2005 4:44 am

I like Ryan too....

And I saw that thing about Scott... talking about blowing something WAY out of proportion.
Yeah it said he was arrested for domestic violence.... which means.. He got into an arguement with his girlfriend and she called the cops on him.
The only thing the police report said was that he grabbed her hand and took off the engagement ring.
Nothing about hitting or pushing or any such thing as alot of people will think when they here "domestic violence".
I think this is really going to hurt him next episode.

Sat Apr 02, 2005 5:25 pm

Shollia wrote:I like Ryan too....

And I saw that thing about Scott... talking about blowing something WAY out of proportion.
Yeah it said he was arrested for domestic violence.... which means.. He got into an arguement with his girlfriend and she called the cops on him.
The only thing the police report said was that he grabbed her hand and took off the engagement ring.
Nothing about hitting or pushing or any such thing as alot of people will think when they here "domestic violence".
I think this is really going to hurt him next episode.

But even so, he should be kicked. I love his voice but if a girl was kicked out for shoplifting, than he should be kicked out for domestic violence (In a sense).

Sat Apr 02, 2005 5:57 pm

Shollia wrote:I like Ryan too....

And I saw that thing about Scott... talking about blowing something WAY out of proportion.
Yeah it said he was arrested for domestic violence.... which means.. He got into an arguement with his girlfriend and she called the cops on him.
The only thing the police report said was that he grabbed her hand and took off the engagement ring.
Nothing about hitting or pushing or any such thing as alot of people will think when they here "domestic violence".
I think this is really going to hurt him next episode.

Actually, according to the stuff I read...he first claimed that he would take their baby, attempted to snatch it, then also threw (and broke) a phone at her. He was charged for felony domestic violence, which later got reduced to misdemeanor disorderly conduct.

http://music.yahoo.com/read/news/18129509
http://music.yahoo.com/read/news/18126453

Sat Apr 02, 2005 7:25 pm

This thing is hillarious:

http://newgrounds.com/portal/view/227808

It's so true.

I want either Anwar, Constantine or Bo to win.

Sat Apr 02, 2005 8:05 pm

Yoshi wrote:
Shollia wrote:I like Ryan too....

And I saw that thing about Scott... talking about blowing something WAY out of proportion.
Yeah it said he was arrested for domestic violence.... which means.. He got into an arguement with his girlfriend and she called the cops on him.
The only thing the police report said was that he grabbed her hand and took off the engagement ring.
Nothing about hitting or pushing or any such thing as alot of people will think when they here "domestic violence".
I think this is really going to hurt him next episode.

Actually, according to the stuff I read...he first claimed that he would take their baby, attempted to snatch it, then also threw (and broke) a phone at her. He was charged for felony domestic violence, which later got reduced to misdemeanor disorderly conduct.

http://music.yahoo.com/read/news/18129509
http://music.yahoo.com/read/news/18126453

So they kick off someone who shop lifts and had her slate cleaned but they don't kick off an abusive boyfriend? I'm sorry, that's stupid. Even if he came clean, I'd kick him off.

This thing is hillarious:

http://newgrounds.com/portal/view/227808

It's so true.

I want either Anwar, Constantine or Bo to win.

He spelt "Idol" wrong. But it was a good flash.

And Anwar, Constantine and Bo don't deserve to win. Anwar seems to act all "I have such a beautiful voice. Worship me!" and Constantine does not even have a great voice. His voice is nice but not Top 10 nice. And Bo, is a wedding singer.

Go Vonzelle!

Sat Apr 02, 2005 11:19 pm

I like Bo Bice man, I hate Costintine he's what I call the babyfaced rocker. I don't really care about the others. Oh yea have you guys of the Numa Numa dance, next year he better try out I'll laugh if he does, plus William Hung has to come back and the on guy that went "CAN YOU DIG IT!!!!" alot.

Sun Apr 03, 2005 7:49 pm

I'm not saying they should have kept Scott on, specially if they've kicked out other people due to being arrested for whatever reason.
Just saying that who the heck cares if he got into an arguement that Probably was blown way out of proportion.
I'm sure some of us have said some pretty nasty things to people we've argued with before.

But anyways, this will most probably hurt him next time anyway. Arrested + a cruddy performance= Not gonna last very long.

Sun Apr 03, 2005 8:07 pm

This is the first American Idol that I've seen in which I'd be happy to see ANY of the finalists win (well, after Mikalia was voted off). I pretty much like all of them, but of course, I do have my favorites. My absolute favorite (and my mom's as well, haha) is Constantine. Then I'd say Bo (he is so good, he's has a good voice and the great stage presence to match), and Anwar.

I definitely think the group of guys is better than the group of girls that they got this year. There's only been 2 or 3 girls that I've been impressed with this season.

Mon Apr 04, 2005 1:55 am

Its a shame that Nadia is always in the bottom 3, I think she is very talented.

Tue Apr 05, 2005 2:43 am

Nadia and Vonzell have got IT!
She wasn't loud enough last week.
And I honestly loved when she sang Time After Time.
If Bo wins, I'll never watch american idol again.

Wed Apr 06, 2005 2:06 am

Whoever thought that having a show tunes as the song choices needs to be kicked swiftly and very hard right in their butt.

Tonight was just horrible.
I was bored out of my mind and just wanted them all to shut their pie holes.

Scott- Not good
Constantine- Not good
Carry- She was good, but boring as heck
Vonzell- Good but boring
Bo- Alright but boring
Nikko- Can't stand him and he did ok
Anthony- Not good

VERY boring AI tonight... very very boring and disappointing.