American Idol 05 (Split)

Sat Apr 09, 2005 6:52 am

watericesage wrote:Pah! First they eliminate Jessica, now they eliminate Nikko...

They're killing off my favorites, its a conspiracy! >.>

But seriously, I would rather have the judges decide who gets voted off until the final five or something...

I'm sorry. *big hug* I don't doubt somebody will pick them up in a recording contract.

Anyways.. about the judges deciding who gets voted off.. I'm not sure I like that idea, because then someone really good that wasn't their taste might be kicked off.

Sat Apr 09, 2005 6:17 pm

Kitten Medli wrote:
watericesage wrote:Pah! First they eliminate Jessica, now they eliminate Nikko...

They're killing off my favorites, its a conspiracy! >.>

But seriously, I would rather have the judges decide who gets voted off until the final five or something...

I'm sorry. *big hug* I don't doubt somebody will pick them up in a recording contract.

Anyways.. about the judges deciding who gets voted off.. I'm not sure I like that idea, because then someone really good that wasn't their taste might be kicked off.

I'm sure Paula would be there to back them up, haha

Sat Apr 09, 2005 8:07 pm

bluebubblegirl wrote:
Kitten Medli wrote:
watericesage wrote:Pah! First they eliminate Jessica, now they eliminate Nikko...

They're killing off my favorites, its a conspiracy! >.>

But seriously, I would rather have the judges decide who gets voted off until the final five or something...

I'm sorry. *big hug* I don't doubt somebody will pick them up in a recording contract.

Anyways.. about the judges deciding who gets voted off.. I'm not sure I like that idea, because then someone really good that wasn't their taste might be kicked off.

I'm sure Paula would be there to back them up, haha

She backs everyone up. It's sickening.

Sun Apr 10, 2005 2:40 am

Ammer wrote:She backs everyone up. It's sickening.

Yes it is. So is the way she cuts off Simon o.<

Sun Apr 10, 2005 10:23 am

Chanel wrote:
Ammer wrote:She backs everyone up. It's sickening.

Yes it is. So is the way she cuts off Simon o.<

It's like she likes EVERYONE'S singing.

Sun Apr 10, 2005 12:18 pm

Chanel wrote:
Ammer wrote:She backs everyone up. It's sickening.

Yes it is. So is the way she cuts off Simon o.<

I know that annoys me so much. Yeah, so simon can get harsh occossionally, but she always cuts him off. Let the man speak his turn. And it's one thing to be positive toward everyone, but she seriously fights him on every contestant and some just don't deserve to be backed up.

Sun Apr 10, 2005 7:16 pm

rageaholic wrote:
Chanel wrote:
Ammer wrote:She backs everyone up. It's sickening.

Yes it is. So is the way she cuts off Simon o.<

I know that annoys me so much. Yeah, so simon can get harsh occossionally, but she always cuts him off. Let the man speak his turn. And it's one thing to be positive toward everyone, but she seriously fights him on every contestant and some just don't deserve to be backed up.

I think there's an ego issue and she refuses to admit that people want to hear him speak much more than her.

Tue Apr 12, 2005 1:38 am

coming2atvnearu wrote:
rageaholic wrote:
Chanel wrote:
Ammer wrote:She backs everyone up. It's sickening.

Yes it is. So is the way she cuts off Simon o.<

I know that annoys me so much. Yeah, so simon can get harsh occossionally, but she always cuts him off. Let the man speak his turn. And it's one thing to be positive toward everyone, but she seriously fights him on every contestant and some just don't deserve to be backed up.

I think there's an ego issue and she refuses to admit that people want to hear him speak much more than her.

I think thats her way of flirting with him, hahaha. But Paula has to be there, there has to be a judge that always tells u something positive. Its sad, but she will compliment you even if you burp an entire song.

Tue Apr 12, 2005 6:31 am

bluebubblegirl wrote:
coming2atvnearu wrote:
rageaholic wrote:
Chanel wrote:
Ammer wrote:She backs everyone up. It's sickening.

Yes it is. So is the way she cuts off Simon o.<

I know that annoys me so much. Yeah, so simon can get harsh occossionally, but she always cuts him off. Let the man speak his turn. And it's one thing to be positive toward everyone, but she seriously fights him on every contestant and some just don't deserve to be backed up.

I think there's an ego issue and she refuses to admit that people want to hear him speak much more than her.

I think thats her way of flirting with him, hahaha. But Paula has to be there, there has to be a judge that always tells u something positive. Its sad, but she will compliment you even if you burp an entire song.

I'd vote for that!

Wed Apr 13, 2005 1:05 am

When Ryan made fun of Simon and Randy, it was HILARIOUS!
Vonzell was DA BOMB tonight!

Wed Apr 13, 2005 1:06 am

carrie was rawr

Wed Apr 13, 2005 1:10 am

angelfire544 wrote:carrie was rawr

If rawr means bad, than I agree. It was an alright night, nothing really good besides Vonzell.

My predictions for bottom three:

Carrie OR Anthony
Nadia
Scott

Wed Apr 13, 2005 2:28 am

Carrie will most probably never be in the bottom 3.
Her fanbase is too large and it would really surprise me if she were ever to be in the bottom 3.

Tonight was boring though.
It was cute seeing them as wittle cute babies, but other than that I wasn't impressed.
And raise your hand if you hate it when the contestants talk back to the judges.. *raises hand*
There's one thing to joke around with them as Fantasia did last season. When she made comments to them it was all in good humor... but when Scott said whatever it was he said... it made me want to smack him.

My predictions for bottom 3.....

Anwar or Anthony
Scott
Nadia

Personally.... I hope Nadia goes. I was a fan at first, but now nuh uh... she's just gotten horrible.

Wed Apr 13, 2005 3:14 am

Shollia wrote:Carrie will most probably never be in the bottom 3.
Her fanbase is too large and it would really surprise me if she were ever to be in the bottom 3.

Tonight was boring though.
It was cute seeing them as wittle cute babies, but other than that I wasn't impressed.
And raise your hand if you hate it when the contestants talk back to the judges.. *raises hand*
There's one thing to joke around with them as Fantasia did last season. When she made comments to them it was all in good humor... but when Scott said whatever it was he said... it made me want to smack him.

My predictions for bottom 3.....

Anwar or Anthony
Scott
Nadia

Personally.... I hope Nadia goes. I was a fan at first, but now nuh uh... she's just gotten horrible.

"Alot of people wouldn't have the nerve to do this"
That made my Mom almost wanna kill him.

My Predictions on the Bottom 3:

Nadia
Scott
Anthony or Bo

Wed Apr 13, 2005 3:18 am

I really hope Nadia is not kicked off, she is talented, she just needs to egt it together and pick appropriate songs. vonzell was good, Scott sucked. i think Anthony and Anwar improved. Carrie was terrible and missed an entire note at the end which lasted about 5 seconds and I am officially deaf now. i caanot stand it when people try to hit a note, and they fail miserably, thinking that they nailed it.

Anyways, the only person that really deserved to go is Scott this week.
i dont even remmeber what his song was like, I just remember that it was crap, and he was rude to the judges. if the judges don't like you, you have to just suck it up, and get over it.

btw, although constantine did sound good, it sounded more karaoke to me, because he didnt bring himself in to the song, it sounded like he was imitationg freddie mercury. Just not very original. As for Bo Bice, i can't even remember what he sang, because it was that boring.

Good job Vonzell. She was never my favorite, but she proved herself as a great singer today.