PPTTG 7 FINAL ROUND

Message

Flame · #166 Post by **Flame** » Tue Oct 11, 2005 1:09 am

InsanePlushie wrote:does the anime/cartoon rule also include no neopets images?

I'll allow Neopets images.

Pixa · #167 Post by **Pixa** » Tue Oct 11, 2005 4:06 pm

I'll start work on this task later.

I understand the judges comments, especially about the mushroom and leaf dominating. I wanted the icons on my desktop to be visable, which is why I have a faded background, I tried it, so it was more visable, and felt the functionality was reduced by doing so. The reason the leaf is a rather bright red is because it is the MapleStory logo, a red maple leaf. Even if the mushroom is bold though, I like my work to have a focus. In this case, it was the mushroom and the leaf. My icons still fit perfectly on the side, yet, it also has a focal point. Maybe it was a little too bright and dominating, but thought I should include my reasoning.

Amethyst · #168 Post by **Amethyst** » Tue Oct 11, 2005 9:10 pm

Done! I actually like this icon....

Original Image: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v31/l ... 188_01.jpg
Program Used: Photoshop Elements

Good luck everyone! ^^ For the last round, I think we should keep it simple and make sets.

Jasujo · #169 Post by **Jasujo** » Tue Oct 11, 2005 9:22 pm

Amethyst wrote:For the last round, I think we should keep it simple and make sets.

Sets were the first round, though. lol

WIS · #170 Post by **WIS** » Tue Oct 11, 2005 11:31 pm

Program: PSP X
Original Image: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v693/ ... s/hugh.jpg
Surprise! =P

Last round, I think sets. =]

Nikita · #171 Post by **Nikita** » Wed Oct 12, 2005 4:41 am

Icon:

Original: http://desperatefans.org/photogallery/albums/new_houseewives/housewives023.jpg
Program: PSP7
*entry may change*

I think another wallpaper would be fun for the last round.

DM was on fire! · Wed Oct 12, 2005 4:15 pm

You're denying me my Seto Kaiba fangirlishness, Flame. Oh, well. I can do Ty.

Jasujo wrote:
Amethyst wrote:For the last round, I think we should keep it simple and make sets.

Sets were the first round, though. lol

That's the way it's always been though. ^^ So, I'm voting sets. ^^

Amethyst · #173 Post by **Amethyst** » Fri Oct 14, 2005 3:50 am

Out of curiosity, when does this round end? o_O

Neko · #174 Post by **Neko** » Fri Oct 14, 2005 4:49 am

Entry very subject change.

Image Used: Click
Program Used: PS CS2

This is a temporary entry...until I can get back onto my computer that has all my stuff.

[[[ EDIT ]]]

REAL Entry:

Image Used: Click
Program Used: PS CS2

I don't know which I like better. Hehee...I'll stick with this one.

Silja · #175 Post by **Silja** » Fri Oct 14, 2005 12:53 pm

Amethyst wrote:Out of curiosity, when does this round end?

Assuming it will last for 4 days (since it's such a small graphic the contestants are making); Saturday.

DM was on fire! · Fri Oct 14, 2005 4:15 pm

Original Image: http://img414.imageshack.us/img414/8384 ... nal5re.jpg
Programs: PSP 8 and PS 7

Pixa · #177 Post by **Pixa** » Fri Oct 14, 2005 8:49 pm

Original Image: Here
Programs used: Photoshop CS2

I forgot to mention I'd like to do sets for the last round.
I'd like to do sets for the last round.

InsanePlushie · #178 Post by **InsanePlushie** » Fri Oct 14, 2005 10:23 pm

Original: http://www.melisande.nl/ppttg/icequeeno.jpg
Programs used: Photoshop 7

Might change if i have the time

Flame · #179 Post by **Flame** » Sun Oct 16, 2005 3:03 am

Judges, choose 2.

Insane Plushie

Original: http://www.melisande.nl/ppttg/icequeeno.jpg
Programs used: Photoshop 7

Pixa

Original Image: http://www.nickbailey.co.uk/images/leaf ... orange.png
Programs used: Photoshop CS2

DM was on fire!

Original Image: http://img414.imageshack.us/img414/8384 ... nal5re.jpg
Programs: PSP 8 and PS 7

Neko

Original Image: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v199/ ... reused.jpg
Program Used: PS CS2

Nikita

Original: http://desperatefans.org/photogallery/a ... ves023.jpg
Program: PSP7

WIS

Program: PSP X
Original Image: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v693/ ... s/hugh.jpg

Amethyst

Original Image: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v31/l ... 188_01.jpg
Program Used: Photoshop Elements

Silja · #180 Post by **Silja** » Sun Oct 16, 2005 10:59 am

Insane Plushie - I'd say you have a good base for an icon, but it strikes me as way too mellow. The colors are quite alike all over, and even though one can clearly see details and what the image you used is portraying, text etc. it just seems as a blur of different tones of light blue and violet. You would have definitely needed to include something that stands out of the mass.

Pixa - I love the way you have managed to make this icon so warm and inviting, I could start rambling about cozy evenings at the fireplace in autumn, but I won't. The contrast between the darker area around the border and the rest of the icon is a bit too strong, you should have worked you way around that somehow. Maybe you could have included more, faded out leaves in the background too, having just one makes it look somewhat empty.

DM was on fire! - The simplicity in this icon disturbs me a bit, I'd rather see something out of the ordinary, for example a new image effect, imaginative borders etc. that would make me go "wow, that's really clever, I would not have thought of that!". Nevertheless, you have an artistic eye for matching simple things and not going overboard with things, so this icon is well-combined. Maybe you could have moved that guy a bit more to the right, I don't like how "diverse" is literally poking him in the eye.

Neko - Personally I think you have gone a bit too wild with the image effects on this icon. It strikes me as quite messy and I can't get a hold of the theme or feeling you were trying to achieve in this one. The black text on top looks really out of place.

Nikita - Now we're talking LJicon. Your entry is the only one out of all seven that I would regard at as an LJicon instead of an avatar to a random forum, if I didn't know all of these were made as LJicons, I mean. Nice use of color overlays based on the woman's dress, maybe you could have put some more strength in the darker border area though (not much, just a bit).

WIS - Seeing that you chose a red theme for the background I believe you could have made the border a bit more towards that style as well, now it looks a bit too strong. Now that i think about it maybe it would have been a better idea to give it some color like the ones on the man's shirt, making the icon more open and not as boxed-in as with all the black (hopefully at least someone understood what I was going on about just there...). Other than that I think you've done a good job with the rest of the icon.

Amethyst - First of all I would have rather seen you use and anti-aliased brush for the border, instead of making it so choppy with no anti-alias at all. Disregarding the negative critique I think it was very imaginative of you to place the text as you have now and the color-overlay looks good, making the icon stick out of the gray mass.

My votes go to Insane Plushie and Neko.