American Idol 7

[WIS]

I can see why Brooke didn't go home. Millions and millions of fans voted extra because she screwed up a little.

I think she did the right thing. I don't see anything wrong with starting and stopping it. It was only one phrase in, not the middle of the song. Granted, if she mumbled through it like David Archuleta, she would still have been criticized for it, and that wouldn't have gotten her through. In my opinion, Syesha actually did the best that night, but I don't think she's nearly popular enough to win.

Has anyone who has messed up in a song lyrically gone home?

[Ammer]

I can see why Brooke didn't go home. Millions and millions of fans voted extra because she screwed up a little.

I think she did the right thing. I don't see anything wrong with starting and stopping it. It was only one phrase in, not the middle of the song. Granted, if she mumbled through it like David Archuleta, she would still have been criticized for it, and that wouldn't have gotten her through. In my opinion, Syesha actually did the best that night, but I don't think she's nearly popular enough to win.

Has anyone who has messed up in a song lyrically gone home?

I agree with you.

I would've stopped and continued, and everyone was saying that was the most suitable solution for what had happened. Only crazy-drug-popping Paula disagreed.

Personally, if she continued, she would've been more agitated and screwed up the rest of her performance. Glad Carly is gone, I disliked her.

PS - David Cook sucks.

[WIS]

I don't like either David. David Cook is annoying and smug. David Archuleta is less annoying but too Disney. Syesha is bound to pick another Whitney song, and eventually Jason and Brooke's weaker voices wouldn't carry them through (Although they are probably my two favorites right now). I'm predicting a final two of the two Davids.

[3lla]

The only reason why David Archuleta is still there is because of this "Miley Cyrus" affect. Where young people just go OMGOMGOMG hes so hawt, and then just vote for him.
I personally do not like David Archuleta and I think he should go home.

As for David Cook on the other hand, yes hes as smug as hell, and pretty much up himself, but you can't deny that he is actually quite good(even though he did destroy my favourite phantom song >.<). Since Carly left, which I believe should have never happened, I guess that David Cook should win, but he'd up against Achuleta so he'd most likely have nearly no chance of winning.
Syesha I reckon should have gone home a long time ago, and as much as I used to like Brooke, she should've left after doing that horrendous performance of under the sunrise or whatever it was.

[Callie]

I agree that Brooke and Sayesha should have been long gone. I also think that the final two will be the two davids. I like both of them, but recently David Cook has become my favorite.
I'm really not sure where Jason fits in, he seems to me to just kinda float around in his own world.

[DM was on fire!]

I meant Brooke. Sorry.
Oh well. She's gone now.

I love Syesha, but I do wonder when she'll be gone.
To quote Joel McHale from The Soup: "And Syesha goes another week being just less than perfect".
...or something. I forget. XD

[3lla]

brookes gone?!

OMG YESH!
*breakdances*

[Pink]

brookes gone?!

OMG YESH!
*breakdances*

My sentiments exactly...though I really really really want Jason to go.

[Callie]

brookes gone?!

OMG YESH!
*breakdances*

My sentiments exactly...though I really really really want Jason to go.

I agree.
I started dancing in my chair when Brooke got kicked off

[3lla]

jason should have gone home a long time ago anyway......I dont like the dreadlock'd one -_-

[Callie]

Ok. Maybe I'm missing something. Could someone tell me why ya'll think David Cook is arrogant?

I also think David Archuletta has potential. I think if he got over some of the shyness he seems to have he'd be loads better, though he's not horrible now.

And Sayesha makes me mad. I think she should have been long gone too. Not to mention that she was shrieking last week.