As you like it - Harry Potter

[Regan]

Charms. Sorry Hagrid.

Norbert or the giant spider I can't remember the name of?

[Siniri]

Norbert! (but only as a baby) -- Aragog eats people, while Norbert only makes your hand turn green.

timeturner or invisibility cloak?

[Byakuya San]

Timeturner!

Fiendfire or Basilisk venom?

[Rachel]

basalisk venom - a tad more controllable!

hufflepuff or ravenclaw?

[DM was on fire!]

Ravenclaw.

Albus or Aberforth?

[Rachel]

Albus

expeliamus or avada kadavra?

[May]

Expeliamus (Avada Kadavra is just too mean )

Cedric Diggory or Victor Krum?

[Pardona]

Krum. Not that I don't empathize with Cedric, but he's just too goodie-two-shoes for me.

Silencio or Protego?

[hpfanfiction]

Protego
Ernie McMillian or Justin Finch-Fletchley?

[Pardona]

Ernie. He's a good chap, he is.

Floo Powder or Portkey?

[hpfanfiction]

Portkey- floo powder doesn't sound too good for my asthma
Crups or Kneazles?

[Pardona]

Kneazles. What's so interesting about Crups?

Being possessed or put under the Imperius Curse?

[Regan]

Being possessed. It's cooler.

Cho Chang or Lavender Brown?

[Pardona]

Cho. At least she has some spirit.

Being Dumbledore and watching over Harry, knowing what he has to come to,
or
being Harry, and being constantly fussed over and shoved into the centre of attention, while just trying to lead an average life?

[hpfanfiction]

Being Dumbledore- I wouldn't want to be Harry- is early life was just so hard
Seeker or Chaser?