WW36: Battle for Middle-Earth Game Thread - GAME OVER

[Regan]

Win Condition: You are so awesome, you win no matter what. Those suckers.

Just thought everyone should know. Sorry.

[loser]

Nice Regan. Niiice.

Stay: Rivendell

Is there a bus-driver type role in this game? What could possibly lead to dream taints besides that?
I'm so on the fence with Ammer...

[Pixa]

The thing is, the innocents need to do something. There has been nothing to say that Ammer's result was incorrect (someone might have stepped forward), and the role is quite an easy one to fake (though it becomes obvious that the role is fake as the game continues), but I found it quite convincing. I know I shouldn't have because I've seen this kinda thing many times before. Hm.

[Rubywinged]

vote: Byakuya (word on the street says they is evil)
Vote: Ammer (cause i'm not convinced either way and would rather be safe then sorry)

move: Rivendell

edited cause i miss spoke

[loser]

Vote: Byakuya

This street has been pretty good.

[Byakuya San]

vote: Byakuya (word on the street says they is evil)
edited cause i miss spoke

Oh really? I'm curious as to who your source is, as this seems to have come out of nowhere. I'm actually very suspicious of this whole deal--first I lose my ability to use special powers, then I get denounced as evil. I recommend that the dreamer dream of me again tonight to clear my name.

Until that happens:
Vote: Ammer
Move: Bree

[loser]

Jas's votes came out of thin air... and look how that turned out.

[Byakuya San]

Jas's votes came out of thin air... and look how that turned out.

Though you have a point there, I'm not another Jas. Whether or not you chose to believe me is entirely your choice, I suppose, but I really think another dream would leave us better off.

[Rubywinged]

Well so far all i've been told is true. And at this point in the Game it's a good time to trust info thats been true before then to doubt for me. Others can draw there own conclusions if they so wish.

[Ammer]

After speaking with Byakuya San, his role definitely seems plausible.

I'm going to hold off my vote for now.

Move: Rivendell

[May]

I personally would like to know what the evidence is against Byakuya and where exactly it came from. There have been two fishy results now, and this most recent one couldn't have come from our role-line dreamer as he's now dead. I'm a little suspicious at this point...

[Wind]

I really don't see the point of voting for Ammer right now. He's given us a role, and if it's fake we'll find out by tomorrow. We can afford to wait another day.

[Pickles]

Pardona, for pie's sake! I'm not a suspect (unless someone comes out with a decent reason to suspect me - unlikely) so I see no reason to defend myself.

You may not quote anything we have PMed you.

Anything. This includes the winning condition, and I've played enough WW games to know. That rule was put in place for a reason, and it's precisely to avoid ridiculous situations like this.

As I posted on the dead thread, this is exactly correct. No one is allowed to directly quote their role sheets.

[Katherine]

I'd like to see some evidence on Byakuya San

Vote: Ammer
Move: Rivendell

[May]

I have been informed that the evidence against Byakuya is a dream result. However, knowing what I know about Byakuya's role, it's expected that he would be dreamt as evil (kind of like an untrustworthy innocent is dreamt as evil). And I agree with Wind... Give Ammer a day or two to prove his role, as he's told many of us, he will.

Vote: DM - for staying in Isengard the whole game... 'tis a bad place